The Wanderer reading room

Game Reviews

Idle RPGs, MMOs, browser games and mobile RPGs, taken apart properly. Every review carries a score out of 10, what the game does well, what it does badly, and the kind of player it is actually for.

Browse the reviews

Action, Adventure, RPGWindows PC

Onimusha: Way of the Sword

Capcom's first new mainline Onimusha in two decades delivers genuinely excellent combat feel and presentation that draws strong praise from both longtime fans and newcomers, undercut by a specific, well-diagnosed launch crash tied to uncapped frame rates, extremely widely corroborated over-tutorialization, a difficulty many players on both sides call too easy, and a live, unresolved identity dispute over whether the game preserves the franchise's classic DNA or wears it as skin over generic modern souls-like design.

7 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Onimusha: Way of the Sword

Action, IndieWindows PC

Orb Tower

A cheap, charming bubble-popping roguelike Orb Tower takes the Puzzle Bobble formula — clear a field of colour-matched bubbles with a limited number of shots before they reach the

6.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Orb Tower

Whimsical farming and exploration life-simWindows PC

Oriental Valley

A visually striking, deliberately surreal farming-and-exploration life-sim whose deadpan-comedic writing and stylised world win over a genuine share of players, held back by a rough translation, sparse post-launch support, and NPCs so minimally detailed that reviewers can't agree whether it's an intentional charm or a sign of an unfinished game.

5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Oriental Valley

Tactical RPG, RogueliteWindows PC

Othercide

A striking black-white-and-blood-red tactical roguelite that reviewers near-unanimously call one of the best-looking games in the genre, undercut by a widely repeated complaint that its boss encounters and checkpoint placement cross from punishing into unfair.

6.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Othercide

Tower Defense, IncrementalWindows PC

Outhold

A tight, well-liked tower-defense incremental whose deep upgrade tree turns out, according to a remarkably consistent chorus of its own reviewers, to be less about creative build freedom and more about puzzling out the one specific combination each of its ten levels actually demands.

6.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Outhold

Clicker, Visual Novel, RPGWindows PC

Path of the Bogatyr

A Slavic-folklore clicker built in the visual-novel engine Ren'Py, whose thin, overwhelmingly one-line foreign-language review score is directly contradicted by Steam's own achievement data — every single achievement sits at almost exactly 1% completion, independently confirming a detailed critical review's claim that almost nobody who buys this game plays it for long.

2.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Path of the Bogatyr

Idle, Auto Battler, GachaWindows PC

Pawns of War

A free, no-microtransaction gun-collecting autobattler openly inspired by Girls' Frontline, whose own official AI-content disclosure — limited to "background images in the novel" and level objects — is disputed by a recurring, independently-argued cluster of reviewers who say the actual extent of AI-generated art and writing goes considerably further than the store page admits.

5.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Pawns of War

Meditative first-person penguin-care toyWindows PC

Penguin Helper

A deliberately tiny, meditative toy built around a single real-world viral phenomenon — penguins falling over when planes fly overhead — whose charm wins over a genuinely devoted niche audience for exactly as long as its handful of interactions stay novel, and not much longer.

4.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Penguin Helper

JRPGWindows PCPlayStationXbox

Persona 3 Reload

ATLUS rebuilds its genre-defining 2006 JRPG from the ground up with modern combat, full voice acting and a gorgeous new engine — a near-unanimous critical success undercut by a well-documented, still-discussed bait-and-switch over what the premium edition's DLC actually included.

8.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Persona 3 Reload

Bullet-heaven roguelite with farming-sim elementsWindows PC

Pesticide Not Required

A charming bullet-heaven roguelite that casts you as a frog defending your farm from corrupted critters while planting crops, fishing, and mining between waves, whose likable twist on the genre earns genuine affection undercut by a widely repeated, specific complaint that its weapon and build variety runs out well before its playtime does.

6 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Pesticide Not Required

Pinball-metroidvania hybridWindows PCNintendo Switch

Pinball Spire

A charming "pinballvania" that fuses forgiving, no-fail-state pinball tables with light exploration and ability-gated progression, whose art style and generous design earn real affection undercut by a widespread, specific dispute over whether it earns its metroidvania framing and a near-universal complaint that its two-to-three-hour runtime doesn't match its price.

5.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Pinball Spire

Simulation, Time Management, NarrativeWindows PC

Pixel Cafe

A time-management cafe sim that pairs genuinely well-regarded, emotionally resonant coming-of-age storytelling with fast, arcade-style service gameplay — undercut by mouse controls several reviewers say the game wasn't really designed for, and a late-game slide into repetitive stations and extreme difficulty swings.

7 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Pixel Cafe

Anomaly-detection horror walking simWindows PC

Platform 8

A spiritual sequel to the beloved anomaly-detection horror game The Exit 8, trading its predecessor's tense "spot the difference and turn back" structure for a forward-only survive-the-anomaly loop, a bold reinvention that a large portion of returning fans feel abandons exactly what made the original special.

5.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Platform 8

Simulation, Casual, ProductivityWindows PC

PomoFarm

A Pomodoro focus timer fused with a tiny idle farm, overwhelmingly loved by a review corpus full of people describing real help with procrastination, ADHD and depression — held back from a perfect score by a specific season-transition bug that can quietly lock progress, and a content ceiling dedicated users eventually hit.

8 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of PomoFarm

Voxel Action RPGWindows PCmacOS

Portal Knights

A voxel-based co-op action RPG that promises to let you "craft your adventure, forge your hero" across floating fantasy islands, Very Positive across nearly 17,000 reviews for its charm and accessibility — while a consistent complaint since launch argues the content underneath doesn't expand fast enough to match its ambition.

5.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Portal Knights

Casual, Indie, Simulation, StrategyWindows PC

POTUS Election Sim

An ambitious political career simulator built around an on-device AI that reads and judges the player's own written responses to debates and crises, undermined by a judging system reviewers describe as inconsistent, easily gamed by response length, and prone to repeating the same scenarios regardless of prior choices.

4.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of POTUS Election Sim

Simulation, CasualWindows PC

Prescribe and Pray

A darkly comedic medical spin on Papers, Please that genre fans consistently enjoy for its humor and paperwork-checking tension, undermined by a specific, well-corroborated crash at the transition to the game's second day, unclear rule feedback that reviewers actively dispute the fairness of, and a currency with nothing to spend it on.

6 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Prescribe and Pray

Simulation, Action, MultiplayerWindows PC

Prison Life 2

A genuinely liked first-person prisoner-and-guard escape sim, undone for most buyers by a single, dominant problem its own most-upvoted review states in six words — nobody is playing it — a complaint that persisted for over a year despite the developer's own repeated attempts to fix it.

4.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Prison Life 2

Tactical Auto-Battler, Management SimulationWindows PC

Private Military Manager: Tactical Auto Battler

A genuinely clever mercenary-management auto-battler that KRAFTON's studio partner abandoned just 73 days into Early Access, confirmed by the developer's own announcement rather than review-corpus rumour — leaving a 3-4 hour prologue standing in for the game it was going to be.

4.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Private Military Manager: Tactical Auto Battler

Incremental, IdleWindows PC

Progress Racer RPG

A short, deliberately-finishable incremental about an endlessly-driving car that most of its own audience calls one of the smartest things to happen to the genre in years — and a detailed minority report that argues it fails as an idler, an incremental and an RPG all at once, over a story some reviewers found genuinely uncomfortable rather than just weak.

7 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Progress Racer RPG

Open World, Narrative Adventure, Management SimWindows PC

Promise Mascot Agency

Kaizen Game Works, the studio behind Paradise Killer, turns a Yakuza-style business side-story into a full open-world game about rehabilitating a cursed Japanese town through mascot management — a passionately loved, distinctly written game whose Overwhelmingly Positive score sits alongside a detailed, substantial minority who found the open-world driving and collecting underneath all that charm genuinely repetitive.

7.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Promise Mascot Agency