Sunset Routes
A tiny, charming Uncharted Waters-inspired crew-and-trading roguelite that exceeds every expectation its NZ$1.49 price tag sets, held back by real reported bugs and thin variety once its handful of endings are seen.
6.5 / 10
The Wanderer reading room
Game Reviews
Idle RPGs, MMOs, browser games and mobile RPGs, taken apart properly. Every review carries a score out of 10, what the game does well, what it does badly, and the kind of player it is actually for.
Browse the reviews
SUPER BOMBERMAN COLLECTION
An exceptionally curated retro collection featuring previously untranslated Bomberman titles, extensive extras and genuine preservation care, undermined for a large share of its own fanbase by the total absence of online multiplayer or Remote Play Together, plus specific reported audio bugs and a VSync-related speed glitch on high-refresh-rate monitors.
6.5 / 10
Supercar Collection Simulator
Diecast gacha, minus the real-money risk Supercar Collection Simulator puts players behind the counter of a diecast toy car shop: unbox surprise car packs, build out a growing coll
5.5 / 10
SUPERHOT
A landmark first-person shooter where time only moves when you do, Very Positive across more than 16,200 reviews for a genuinely innovative, widely imitated core mechanic — dominated by an extremely consistent complaint that its two-to-three-hour campaign doesn't match its asking price, alongside a specific, repeatedly cited controversy over content the developer removed years after release, a forced third-party launcher, and a real photosensitivity warning several reviewers say the game needs.
7 / 10
Suzerain
A text-driven political drama that casts the player as the president of a fictional post-colonial nation, earning praise as close to a genre landmark for its writing and worldbuilding, while a large, detailed share of reviewers push back hard on how little direct control the actual mechanics give the choices that supposedly define it.
7.5 / 10
Sword and Fairy Inn 2
A nostalgia-driven inn-management sequel bringing back beloved characters from Softstar's decades-old Sword and Fairy RPG series, genuinely charming for longtime fans but criticised by a large share of its own audience for stripping out the exploration depth that made the original stand out.
5.5 / 10
SYMMETRY
SYMMETRY wraps a survival-management sim in genuinely striking retro-futuristic vector art and a mysterious, half-told sci-fi story. Its own reviewers largely agree the atmosphere is the best thing about it, and just as largely agree the actual click-and-wait management loop underneath is one of the most punishing, repetitive experiences in the genre.
5 / 10
Tank Team
A free-to-play co-op tank-crewing PvP game whose "everyone has a job inside one tank" concept earns genuine, specific praise from players who found a full crew, undercut by a large, specific negative-review consensus that the live playerbase is now too thin to reliably find matches, and by a confusing free-demo-versus-paid-DLC structure several reviewers call misleading.
5 / 10
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Empire City
A VR open-world beat-em-up whose parkour movement and genuine TMNT fan service earn real praise, undermined by broken grip controls on Index headsets, a small and lifeless open-world hub, shallow repetitive combat, and a co-op multiplayer system reviewers say only works via private room codes rather than public matchmaking.
5 / 10
Tell Me Why
DONTNOD's Alaska-set mystery about twins piecing together a shared, supernatural childhood memory is gorgeous and well-intentioned, but a large share of its own audience, including many who loved Life is Strange, say the writing and interactivity don't match the studio's earlier work — a critique this review treats as separate from the political backlash the game's trans protagonist also drew.
6 / 10
Ten Trials of Babel: The Doppelganger Maze
A cheap, fully-voiced otome death-game puzzle RPG whose writing and cast earned it an outsized, devoted following, held back by a rough English localization — including one reviewer-flagged slur that shouldn't have made it to release — and an unresolved bug that blocks progress specifically on the Mac version the store page advertises.
7 / 10
The Almost Gone
A somber diorama puzzle game about death, memory and family tragedy, atmospheric enough to move some players deeply — and undercut for many others by story that never quite resolves, fiddly rotation-based puzzles, and achievements several reviewers single out as an actively bad design choice.
5.5 / 10
The Amazing American Circus
A card-battling circus-management RPG set in post-Civil War America, Mixed across a small sample of Steam reviews for its distinctive theme and art — undercut by an extremely consistent complaint that its circus setting is a thin cosmetic reskin over standard deckbuilder mechanics, poor tutorialization, and a widely repeated sense among reviewers that the resulting gameplay is simply boring.
5 / 10
The Artful Escape
A psychedelic, guitar-shredding side-scrolling adventure about a young musician escaping his uncle's folk-legend shadow, Very Positive across nearly 900 reviews for its stunning visual spectacle — undercut by an extremely consistent complaint that the actual gameplay is shallow and repetitive, a well-corroborated complaint about unchanging, repetitive music, and a specific progression-blocking bug this review found no evidence of being patched.
6 / 10
The Bard's Tale IV: Director's Cut
A puzzle-heavy first-person dungeon crawler reviving a classic RPG name, praised for tactical combat, songs and voice work, but weighed down by a genuinely large volume of documented bugs, a puzzle-to-roleplay ratio that surprises and frustrates a substantial share of buyers, and restrictive character-building choices.
6 / 10
The Braves
A free-to-play Vampire Survivors-style bullet-heaven whose genuinely fun opening hours are widely praised, before a large, remarkably consistent negative-review consensus describes a punishing grind wall and aggressive gacha monetization that Steam's own promotional feed for the game — almost entirely sale and summon-banner announcements — directly corroborates.
4.5 / 10
THE CASE OF THE LAST SHAWARMA
A short, stylish noir-parody detective visual novel that unanimously delights its very small early review sample with absurd witness interrogations, a striking black-grey-and-gold art style, and five distinct investigation minigames, tempered only by a report of unclear or poorly-localised dialogue for at least one non-native English reader.
7.5 / 10
The Cave
Ron Gilbert's Double Fine puzzle-platformer sends three chosen adventurers, out of seven available, into a talking, wish-granting cave to confront their own dark pasts — reviewers consistently praise its charm and writing, while a specific, well-documented complaint argues the advertised co-op mode barely functions as co-op at all.
6.5 / 10
The Crush House
A genuinely inventive reality-TV cameraman sim from Reigns developer Nerial, published by Devolver Digital, whose original premise and art direction earn wide admiration for a first playthrough, undercut by a remarkably consistent negative-review theme describing repetitive dialogue after the first season, an unresolved mystery that never pays off, and at least one persistent progress-blocking bug the developer appears to have stopped patching.
5.5 / 10
The Electrifying Incident: A Monster Mini-Expedition
A tiny expedition from a trusted puzzle studio The Electrifying Incident is a bite-sized standalone spinoff from Draknek and Friends, the studio behind the widely acclaimed A Monst
6.5 / 10
Read review of The Electrifying Incident: A Monster Mini-Expedition
The End Is Nigh
The End Is Nigh sends a small, sad blob named Ash through hundreds of brutal precision platforming levels in a decaying post-apocalyptic world, from Super Meat Boy co-creator Edmund McMillen. Its level design and dark tone earn genuine praise, while a specific, recurring complaint about a finite-lives second chapter and a lack of meaningful long-term reward keep it from a clean sweep.
7 / 10
The Escapists 2
The Escapists 2 sends up to four players into a series of increasingly elaborate prisons to plot their breakout through crafting, routine-management, and careful rule-breaking. Its sandbox premise draws real, sustained praise, tempered by a specific, well-documented complaint that escape plans are far more scripted than the marketing suggests, and by a development history that's been effectively dormant for years.
6.5 / 10
The Falconeer
A solo developer's beautiful, steampunk-tinged open-world war-bird combat game, weighed down at launch by floaty controls and a repetitive fly-fight-fly-back mission loop that a genuine, years-long remaster effort has since worked to address.
6 / 10
The Forgotten City
A time-loop mystery RPG expanded from an award-winning Skyrim mod into a full standalone release, Overwhelmingly Positive across more than 7,300 reviews for its ambitious premise and dialogue-driven investigation — undercut by a consistent backlash against its hype, thin walking-sim gameplay dressed as an RPG, dated production values, and a widely criticised "canon" ending that many reviewers feel undercuts the story it spent hours building.
6.5 / 10