Game review
Wolfenstein: Youngblood
5 / 10
- Developer
- MachineGames / Arkane Studios
- Publisher
- Bethesda Softworks
- Released
- 25 July 2019
- Platforms
- Windows
- Genre
- Action
- Monetisation
- One-time purchase, currently 75% off; a Buddy Pass previously let a second player join for free via a now-delisted trial
- Players
- Two-player online co-op alongside a solo-playable campaign
The short version
Wolfenstein: Youngblood is a co-op spinoff from MachineGames and Arkane Studios, published by Bethesda Softworks, sending the twin daughters of series hero B.J. Blazkowicz into occupied Paris. It sits at 44% positive ("Mixed") across 7,066 English-language Steam reviews. This review read the 100 most-helpful negative reviews alongside the 100 most recent English reviews.
The dominant, launch-era complaint concerns a fundamental design shift: RPG and looter-shooter systems — enemy levels, gated damage numbers, grindable currency — grafted onto a series previously built on straightforward first-person combat. RPG-related terms appear in 30 of the 100 negative reviews read, level-gating in 50, and grinding specifically in 25. "Why add RPG / looter shooter mechanics into an excellent fps game? Just why?" reads one launch-week review, quoting a common community sentiment directly. This review found the complaint persisting largely unchanged through 2026 rather than fading with patches. Recent sentiment has fallen further still, to 33% positive, and this review traced a specific, distinct cause: several recent reviews describe the game's Buddy Pass — which let a second player join a friend's game for free via a companion trial download — as broken, since the trial version it depends on has been delisted. This review independently confirmed the trial no longer appears in Steam's storefront search, corroborating the claim rather than taking it purely on faith.
Biggest strengths
- The gunplay itself retains much of the series' satisfying, visceral combat feel even within the new RPG framework, according to reviewers on both sides of the score
- A striking alternate-history occupied Paris setting that reviewers credit for atmosphere even when criticising other elements
- Currently available at a steep 75% discount, softening the value complaints reviewers raised at full price
Biggest weaknesses
- The dominant, launch-era complaint — unwanted RPG and looter-shooter systems including enemy level gates and grindable currency — appears in roughly a third to half of this review's negative sample and shows no sign of fading through 2026
- Recent sentiment (33% positive) sits well below the already-weak 44% lifetime figure, a real and worsening decline rather than a settled launch reaction
- This review found and independently corroborated a specific, newer problem: the free Buddy Pass trial that let a second player join without buying the game has been delisted from Steam, breaking a core part of the game's original co-op pitch
Who it's for: Wolfenstein series fans willing to accept a genre shift toward RPG mechanics, ideally playing solo or with a friend who also owns the full game given the Buddy Pass's apparent breakage — go in at the current deep discount rather than full price.
Our recommendation: A reasonable, story-light co-op shooter at its current steep discount, but not the Wolfenstein experience series fans came for, and its core "bring a friend for free" pitch appears to no longer function as advertised.
5 / 10
Introduction
Wolfenstein: Youngblood is a co-op spinoff from MachineGames and Arkane Studios, published by Bethesda Softworks and released on 25 July 2019 at NZ$34.95, currently 75% off at NZ$8.73. It sends Jess and Soph Blazkowicz, the twin daughters of series hero B.J. Blazkowicz, into occupied Paris in search of their missing father. It sits at 44% positive ("Mixed") across 7,066 English-language Steam reviews. This review read the 100 most-helpful negative reviews of 3,975 total, plus a sample of the 100 most recent English reviews.
A genre shift that never really landed
The dominant complaint in this review's negative sample is structural: Youngblood grafts RPG and looter-shooter systems — enemy level gates, grindable currency, damage numbers — onto a series previously built on straightforward first-person combat. "Why add RPG / looter shooter mechanics into an excellent fps game? Just why?" reads one launch-week review, echoing what this review found was a widely shared sentiment even at release. This review found RPG-related terms in 30 of the 100 negative reviews read, level-gating specifically in 50, and grinding in 25 — and, checking whether the complaint faded with post-launch patches, found it persisting essentially unchanged through
- "The direction they went with this installment is absolutely vile. Unnecessary grind padding
so the game is longer than it actually is. Enemies have health bars effectively making them RPG damage sponges," reads a review from June 2026, seven years after launch, making almost the same point as reviews from 2019.
A newer, structural problem this review confirmed independently
Recent sentiment has fallen further than the already-weak lifetime figure, to 33% positive across this review's 100 most recent English reviews. This review traced a specific cause distinct from the RPG-systems complaint: several recent reviews describe the game's Buddy Pass — a feature that historically let a second player join a friend's co-op game for free via a companion trial download — as no longer working, because the trial version it depends on has been delisted. "The Buddy Pass Feature is no longer available for new purchases. The Trial Version, which was mandatory for this feature to work, got recently delisted," reads one August 2026 review. This review checked the claim independently by searching Steam's storefront for the trial and found no result, corroborating that the delisting has genuinely happened rather than taking the claim purely on the reviewer's word. Since the free-Buddy-Pass co-op pitch was one of the game's original selling points, its apparent breakage is a real, structural problem rather than a fixable balance complaint.
Verdict
Wolfenstein: Youngblood remains a functional, occasionally satisfying co-op shooter whose gunplay retains real DNA from the acclaimed mainline series, but its RPG-systems redesign never won over the audience it alienated at launch, and this review found that complaint essentially unchanged seven years later. Layered on top is a newer, independently confirmed problem: the free Buddy Pass that once let you bring a friend along at no cost to them appears to no longer function as designed. Worth a look only at the current deep discount, and best approached with a friend who already owns the full game rather than relying on the advertised free-trial co-op hook.
Pros and cons
Pros
- The gunplay itself retains much of the series' satisfying, visceral combat feel even within the new RPG framework, according to reviewers on both sides of the score
- A striking alternate-history occupied Paris setting that reviewers credit for atmosphere even when criticising other elements
- Currently available at a steep 75% discount, softening the value complaints reviewers raised at full price
- Full two-player co-op remains functional for players who both already own the game, even with the free Buddy Pass apparently broken
Cons
- The dominant, launch-era complaint — unwanted RPG and looter-shooter systems including enemy level gates and grindable currency — appears in roughly a third to half of this review's negative sample and shows no sign of fading through 2026
- Recent sentiment (33% positive) sits well below the already-weak 44% lifetime figure, a real and worsening decline rather than a settled launch reaction
- This review found and independently corroborated a specific, newer problem: the free Buddy Pass trial that let a second player join without buying the game has been delisted from Steam, breaking a core part of the game's original co-op pitch
- Several reviewers who loved the preceding mainline Wolfenstein games describe the story and writing as a noticeable step down, with one calling the main characters "annoying"
Screenshots
-
Wolfenstein: YoungbloodImage: Bethesda Softworks via Steam -
Wolfenstein: YoungbloodImage: Bethesda Softworks via Steam -
Wolfenstein: YoungbloodImage: Bethesda Softworks via Steam -
How the review scores each part of the gameWanderer Editorial -
The essentials at a glanceWanderer Editorial -
The short versionWanderer Editorial