The Wanderer reading room

Game Reviews

Idle RPGs, MMOs, browser games and mobile RPGs, taken apart properly. Every review carries a score out of 10, what the game does well, what it does badly, and the kind of player it is actually for.

Browse the reviews

Becoming Captain - The Roguelike Deckbuilder

A solo-developed deckbuilder whose one real twist — you draft cards mid-fight instead of only between them, and your wounds follow you into the next battle — has convinced every single one of its handful of Steam reviewers, three months after a launch almost nobody noticed.

7 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Becoming Captain - The Roguelike Deckbuilder

Border Patrol

A tiny-sample Papers Please-style border-inspection sim whose biggest early complaint — no save feature — appears to have been fixed post-launch, alongside a specific unresolved scoring bug and an unverified asset-theft claim from a single reviewer.

5.5 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Border Patrol

Bullet Heaven 2

A solo developer's hand-drawn bullet-hell shoot-em-up from the Epic Battle Fantasy universe, seven years before "bullet heaven" became a genre label for something else entirely — reviewed on its seventy stages, its scalable difficulty, and the Flash-era tech it still carries.

8 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Bullet Heaven 2

Bunker - The Underground Game

A deliberately absurd, meme-heavy point-and-click adventure set in a Soviet bunker, split sharply between reviewers who find its humour genuinely funny and a larger group who find it grating — compounded by illogical puzzle design and bugs the developer stopped patching in early 2016.

3.9 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Bunker - The Underground Game

Cafe Dash: Cooking, Diner Game

A genuinely fun free-to-play Diner Dash-style time-management game, undercut by a real, specific difficulty spike after level 50-60 that reviewers on both sides say pushes hard toward paid boosters, plus a persistent tutorial mode some reviewers say never stops interrupting play.

4.6 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Cafe Dash: Cooking, Diner Game

Car Mechanic Simulator 2014

The rough, genuinely enjoyable first entry in what became a long-running franchise — a puzzle-like repair loop reviewers say works well in short bursts, undercut by real repetition, a lack of goals or garage progression, and a wobbly first-person camera several reviewers say induces motion sickness.

5.3 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Car Mechanic Simulator 2014

Carnival Massacre

A solo-developed PS1-era survival horror throwback with genuine retro charm, undercut by a slow opening act, real launch-day bugs, and a short 1-2 hour runtime — offset by unusually fast, sustained developer patching that this review verified independently.

6.3 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Carnival Massacre

Castle Defense Battles

A NZ$4.79 tower-defense-and-troops hybrid from the studio behind Merge Cats and Merge Beasts. It has collected exactly one Steam review in almost four years — and that review is negative, describing the exact lack of choice this write-up finds in the store listing itself.

3.8 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Castle Defense Battles

Castle Siege

A free, solo-developed medieval action game with a genuinely creative post-apocalyptic twist and a small but enthusiastic fanbase, held back by two basic missing options — no mouse invert and no in-game sound volume control — that this tiny sample's negative reviews cite directly.

6.2 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Castle Siege

Cat Meoir: Feline Detective

A genuinely creative premise — a cat solving its owner's 1950s NYC murder — undone by a camera bug so severe and so consistently described the same way by independent reviewers that it reads less like a rough edge than a fundamental, never-patched flaw.

3.8 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Cat Meoir: Feline Detective

[Chilla's Art] The Ghost Train | 幽霊列車

Even loyal fans of the prolific Chilla's Art horror catalogue widely call this one of the studio's weakest entries — a tedious back-and-forth walking simulator with a genuine progression-blocking bug and a sound-based puzzle with no accessibility option for deaf or hard-of-hearing players.

4.3 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of [Chilla's Art] The Ghost Train | 幽霊列車

Chivalry 2

Some of the best large-scale medieval melee combat available, played by fans who describe hundreds of hours of genuine joy — undercut by a cheating problem serious enough that reviewers report a YouTuber known for helping the studio fight it was permanently banned instead.

7 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Chivalry 2

Claritas - Dungeon Crawler RPG

A four-person turn-based party crawler built almost entirely around class variety and a respec-anytime skill tree, sold once for nine dollars with no ads and no premium currency. The loot loop is the whole pitch, and it works — but the game explains almost none of it to you.

7.2 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Claritas - Dungeon Crawler RPG

Clock Tower: Rewind

The first legal English release of a genuine 1995 horror pioneer, widely described by reviewers as an emulated ROM with a launcher rather than a true remaster — a specific, obtrusive cutscene-unlock popup and missing audio settings draw the sharpest complaints, though this review confirmed the developer rapidly patched several launch-crash issues within weeks.

5.7 / 10

Reviewed

Read review of Clock Tower: Rewind