Game review
Sleeping Dogs: Definitive Edition
7.5 / 10
- Developer
- United Front Games
- Publisher
- Square Enix
- Released
- 8 October 2014
- Platforms
- Windows
- Genre
- Open-World Action
- Monetisation
- One-time premium purchase; this Definitive Edition bundles all original DLC together, superseding and replacing the 2012 original as the only version Steam still sells
- Players
- Single-player only; no online, co-op or PvP modes
The short version
Sleeping Dogs casts players as Wei Shen, an undercover cop infiltrating the Sun On Yee triad in a densely realized Hong Kong, balancing loyalty to the criminal organization he's climbing against the mission he's actually there to complete. Reviewers consistently describe it as a genuine, standalone achievement rather than a GTA clone: "at the time, it felt like a proper alternative to GTA. Not a cheap copy, not a reskin, but its own thing," one reviewer writes, crediting the martial-arts-driven combat, setting and story specifically. Several reviewers express open, specific disappointment that the game never received a sequel.
A real, serious technical flaw runs alongside that praise, worth flagging clearly for this specific edition: save data is stored inside the game's own install directory with no Steam Cloud support, meaning uninstalling, reinstalling, or a drive failure can permanently erase progress. One detailed reviewer reports losing twelve hours this way. A separate, more mixed critique concerns this Definitive Edition specifically: several reviewers argue the re-release carried over bugs from the original without meaningfully fixing them, drawing an unflattering comparison to other re-releases known for the same problem.
Biggest strengths
- A genuinely distinctive open-world setting, with reviewers consistently praising the density and specificity of its Hong Kong recreation compared to more generic open-world cities
- Strong, intuitive martial-arts-based combat that reviewers repeatedly single out as a genre highlight rather than a secondary system bolted onto driving and shooting
- A well-regarded, character-driven undercover-cop story that reviewers say holds up as genuinely well written years after release
Biggest weaknesses
- A serious, specific technical flaw: save data is stored inside the game's install directory with no Steam Cloud support, meaning uninstalling, reinstalling, or hardware failure can permanently erase progress; one detailed reviewer reports losing twelve hours of progress this way
- A specific critique of this particular re-release: several reviewers argue bugs present in the original 2012 version were carried over into this Definitive Edition without being meaningfully fixed, drawing a direct comparison to other troubled "definitive" re-releases
- Vehicle handling, particularly motorcycles, is described by multiple reviewers as noticeably weaker than the game's combat and world design
Who it's for: Open-world action fans who want a distinctive setting and genuinely strong hand-to-hand combat system rather than a GTA reskin. Less suited to players who need reliable cloud saves, or anyone specifically hoping this Definitive Edition meaningfully improved on the original's technical issues.
Our recommendation: A genuine, still-underrated genre highlight worth playing for its setting, story and combat alone — just manually back up your save files before uninstalling, since this edition offers no cloud-save safety net.
7.5 / 10
A quick note on edition: the original 2012 release of Sleeping Dogs is no longer sold on Steam, superseded by this Definitive Edition, which bundles the base game with all its original DLC and some visual improvements. This review covers that current, actively sold release.
A genuine alternative to GTA, not an imitation
The praise here is specific and comes from reviewers with real perspective on the open-world genre's other big names. "A reminder of when open-world games actually had soul," one reviewer writes, describing returning to the game years after first playing it on console. "At the time, it felt like a proper alternative to GTA. Not a cheap copy, not a reskin, but its own thing." Another reviewer credits the specific combination that makes it work: "Punching dudes into air conditioners, undercover cop drama, and some of the most fun hand-to-hand combat I've seen in an open-world game." A separate, more analytical review breaks down the game's structure directly: Wei Shen leads a genuine double life as both an undercover cop and an active Triad member, with the story alternating between both sides of that tension rather than treating the undercover premise as a thin excuse for open-world mayhem. Multiple reviewers independently express genuine disappointment that no sequel ever followed, with one writing plainly, "the real crime? We never got a sequel," and another saying they'd personally fund a revival of the now-closed developer if they had the means.
A serious, specific technical flaw with saves
Set against that praise, this review sample surfaces a genuinely serious problem worth flagging with real prominence. "The save data is inside of the ACTUAL GAME INSTALL DIRECTORY, and the game DOESN'T SUPPORT STEAM CLOUD SAVES," one detailed reviewer explains, warning that "uninstalling the game and then reinstalling or having a hard drive / operating system failure" means "ALL OF YOUR PROGRESS GONE." That reviewer reports losing twelve hours of progress this way, describing the missing cloud-save support as something "even indie games have." That's a concrete, specific, and easily avoidable risk as long as buyers know about it going in — back up the save folder manually before any uninstall — but it's a real gap for a major re-release from a large publisher.
A "food" and lifestyle system reviewers wish went further
Beyond combat and story, the game layers in a system of street food, karaoke, and other lifestyle activities that provide temporary stat bonuses when engaged with. Reviewers generally view this system favorably, with one specifically praising it as a system with "no real problems, just wish it was fleshed out more" — a mild but recurring wish that this side of the game had received deeper development, rather than a genuine complaint about what's there. That kind of specific, constructive feedback recurs often enough to suggest the underlying idea landed well even where reviewers wanted more of it.
A mixed verdict on what this specific edition actually fixed
A separate, more pointed critique concerns this Definitive Edition specifically rather than the game's original design. "As with other re-releases (such as Deus Ex: Human Revolution Director's Cut), the remake is more buggy and less graphically optimized than the original," one reviewer writes. A separate, more detailed review agrees with the underlying premise, noting the edition is "just patched original Sleeping Dogs with full DLC and some improvements to the graphic that are either insignificant" in practice. That's worth knowing specifically for anyone deciding whether paying extra for this edition over a used copy of the original actually delivers meaningfully improved technical quality.
What the completion data adds
Steam's achievement statistics offer a useful independent read on engagement here. Early milestones sit above 70% of the tracked playerbase, consistent with a game reviewers describe as approachable and well-paced early on, but that curve falls away toward the harder completionist achievements, several of which sit around 3%. As with several other older titles in this catalogue, the achievement schema here returns only generic internal identifiers rather than readable names, so this review can describe the general shape of that drop-off without tying it to specific story chapters or side-content milestones.
A setting reviewers with real local knowledge vouch for
Beyond general open-world praise, it's worth noting a specific, charming detail from reviewers who actually know Hong Kong firsthand. One writes that the game rearranges real landmarks in geographically inaccurate but clearly loving ways — "Central pier ended up in Aberdeen... Temple street ended up being in North Point" — finding the mishmash funny rather than distracting, and specifically praising the accuracy of smaller details like street signage and cultural references that would be easy for a foreign developer to get wrong. That kind of specific, insider validation is a meaningful signal for how seriously the setting's atmosphere was researched, even where the literal city geography was rearranged for gameplay convenience.
Where it lands
Sleeping Dogs earns its status as a genuinely underrated open-world highlight through a distinctive Hong Kong setting, strong martial-arts combat, and a character-driven story reviewers describe in consistently warm, specific terms years after release. The lack of Steam Cloud save support is a real, serious risk worth protecting against manually, and the mixed reception of this particular re-release's technical improvements is worth factoring into whether it's worth the price premium over the original. For open-world action fans looking for something genuinely distinct from the genre's biggest names, this remains an easy, well-earned recommendation — just guard your save files carefully, since it's the one part of the experience the game itself won't protect for you.
Pros and cons
Pros
- A genuinely distinctive open-world setting, with reviewers consistently praising the density and specificity of its Hong Kong recreation compared to more generic open-world cities
- Strong, intuitive martial-arts-based combat that reviewers repeatedly single out as a genre highlight rather than a secondary system bolted onto driving and shooting
- A well-regarded, character-driven undercover-cop story that reviewers say holds up as genuinely well written years after release
- This Definitive Edition includes all original DLC content bundled together for a modest price increase over the base game alone
- A reasonably paced, non-bloated campaign, with reviewers reporting the main story completable in roughly six to ten hours depending on how many side missions are pursued
Cons
- A serious, specific technical flaw: save data is stored inside the game's install directory with no Steam Cloud support, meaning uninstalling, reinstalling, or hardware failure can permanently erase progress; one detailed reviewer reports losing twelve hours of progress this way
- A specific critique of this particular re-release: several reviewers argue bugs present in the original 2012 version were carried over into this Definitive Edition without being meaningfully fixed, drawing a direct comparison to other troubled "definitive" re-releases
- Vehicle handling, particularly motorcycles, is described by multiple reviewers as noticeably weaker than the game's combat and world design
- Combat can become repetitive over a full playthrough, with more than one reviewer noting that countering attacks becomes the dominant, oversimplified strategy against most enemies
- No sequel was ever produced despite the strong reception, which several reviewers cite as a genuine, ongoing source of disappointment rather than a criticism of this game itself
Screenshots
-
Sleeping Dogs Definitive EditionImage: Square Enix via Steam -
Sleeping Dogs Definitive EditionImage: Square Enix via Steam -
Sleeping Dogs Definitive EditionImage: Square Enix via Steam -
How the review scores each part of the gameWanderer Editorial -
The specsWanderer Editorial -
The short versionWanderer Editorial