Game review
Saints Row: The Third
7.5 / 10
- Developer
- Volition
- Publisher
- Deep Silver
- Released
- 15 November 2011
- Platforms
- Windows
- Genre
- Open-World Action Comedy
- Monetisation
- One-time premium purchase; extensive cosmetic and content DLC available separately
- Players
- Full single-player campaign playable in co-op, alongside separate competitive Whored mode; some legacy online features (character upload) are no longer functional since the original servers were shut down
The short version
Saints Row: The Third puts players in charge of the Third Street Saints, a criminal gang that's grown into a full media and lifestyle brand, defending their turf in the fictional city of Steelport with a mix of over-the-top action, absurdist humor, and deep character customization. Reviewers consistently describe the game's tone and writing as its biggest strength: "Exceptionally funny," "great voice acting," and "over-the-top story" recur constantly, and multiple reviewers specifically credit the game's co-op mode with making an already fun experience even better.
A specific, well-documented technical problem runs alongside that praise: the game still attempts to connect to online services that were shut down years ago, and reviewers report this causes a reproducible stuttering bug affecting even the main menu and opening cinematic, with a community-made fix guide required to resolve it. A separate, specific regional issue affects some countries directly — Australia and Germany historically received a "low violence" version incompatible with saves from the uncensored release. A third, more unusual finding recurs too: several reviewers specifically recommend buying this original release over its pricier, Epic Games Store-exclusive remaster.
Biggest strengths
- Genuinely funny, absurdist writing and strong voice acting that reviewers consistently rank as the series' comedic peak
- Deep character, vehicle, and weapon customization that reviewers say adds real personal investment beyond the core action gameplay
- Enjoyable, well-supported co-op that multiple reviewers specifically recommend as the best way to experience the game
Biggest weaknesses
- A specific, well-documented technical problem: the game still attempts to connect to shut-down online services, causing a reproducible stuttering bug affecting even the main menu, requiring a community-made fix guide to resolve
- A regional content issue affecting some countries historically: Australia and Germany received a "low violence" version incompatible with save files from the uncensored release, worth checking directly if you're in an affected region
- One achievement specifically requires uploading a character to now-defunct online servers, requiring a community mod workaround to obtain
Who it's for: Open-world action-comedy fans who want genuinely absurdist humor and deep character customization rather than a straight-faced crime story. Less suited to players in regions historically affected by the censored version, or anyone who can't tolerate the reported stuttering bug without applying a community fix first.
Our recommendation: A genre-comedy classic well worth the low asking price — apply the community stutter-fix guide if you experience menu lag, and check regional version details if you're in a historically affected country.
7.5 / 10
Saints Row: The Third picks up three years after its predecessor, with the Third Street Saints no longer just a criminal gang but a full media empire complete with merchandising and energy drinks, before a bank heist gone wrong drags them into a war with a much larger criminal syndicate in the fictional city of Steelport. This review sample confirms the game's reputation as the series' comedic high point, while surfacing a specific, well-documented technical problem worth understanding before buying.
Writing and customization reviewers consistently rank as the series' best
The praise here is specific and enthusiastic. "The only game on the market that lets you bludgeon a couple of furries to death with a twelve-inch dildo," one detailed pros-and-cons review opens, before listing "exceptionally funny," "great voice acting," and a "likable cast of characters" among its strengths. A separate reviewer describes deliberately slowing their own playthrough down to savor the story, taking on five or six side quests between each main mission specifically to extend the experience. Character, vehicle, and weapon customization draw their own specific praise throughout, with reviewers describing genuine personal investment in building out their version of the Saints' boss beyond what the core missions require, from cosmetic outfits down to the performance tuning of individual vehicles.
A specific, well-documented dead-server bug
Set against that praise, a concrete technical problem recurs across multiple independent reviews. "As of April 20, 2021, there's a critical bug with the game," one reviewer writes. "Because it tries to connect to dead servers, even the opening cinematic and main menu will be laggy and stuttering," pointing to a community-made "Lag/Stutter Fix" guide as the only known workaround. A separate reviewer confirms the same root cause more casually: "the game crashes due to old online services they have not removed from the PC version." That's a specific, reproducible, and well-corroborated issue distinct from general optimization complaints, and applying the community fix appears to be a practical necessity rather than an optional tweak for many players, particularly on newer hardware where the game would otherwise be expected to run flawlessly.
An achievement locked behind dead servers
One further, oddly specific technical footnote is worth including for completionists: one achievement in this game requires uploading a custom character to the game's original online servers, which were shut down years ago, making the achievement impossible to earn through normal means. A reviewer notes a community-made mod exists to emulate the shut-down service specifically to unlock this one achievement, a workaround worth knowing about directly for anyone chasing full completion rather than discovering the dead-end through trial and error.
A regional censorship issue, and a case for buying this over the remaster
Two further, more specific findings are worth passing along directly. Historically, Australia and Germany received a "low violence" version of the game due to regional content restrictions, which one detailed reviewer specifically warns is incompatible with save files from the uncensored version — worth checking directly if you're in an affected region. Separately, and more unusually, several reviewers explicitly recommend buying this original release over its newer remaster: "DO NOT PURCHASE THE REMASTERED VERSION OF THE GAME, THIS ONE IS JUST AS GOOD," one writes, listing specific character-model complaints about the remaster before noting its exclusivity to a different storefront at a considerably higher price. That's a genuinely useful piece of comparative buying advice worth passing along directly.
What the completion data confirms
This listing's achievement schema uses readable, thematically named entries, and the resulting curve confirms a widely accessible early game followed by a steep drop toward full completion. Early story achievements sit at 87-90% of the tracked playerbase, but that falls away sharply toward optional activities and side-content achievements, several of which sit around 3-4%. One detailed completionist reviewer captures this pattern directly, describing walking away from several remaining assassinations, car thefts, and side activities specifically because "the diminishing returns" of chasing full completion stopped being worth the tedium — a specific, honest account of exactly where the game's replay value runs out for even dedicated players.
A tonal turning point for the franchise
It's worth situating this game within the wider Saints Row series, since reviewers frequently frame their praise in exactly those terms. This entry marked a deliberate shift away from the grittier, more grounded tone of the first two games toward full embrace of over-the-top absurdist comedy, a change reviewers in this sample overwhelmingly credit as the right call for the series' identity. At least one detailed reviewer specifically laments the direction the eventual sequel, Saints Row IV, and later entries took certain characters, arguing this game represents the peak of a specific creative approach the franchise never quite recaptured afterward — context worth knowing for anyone deciding where to start in the series.
Where it lands
Saints Row: The Third earns its reputation as the series' comedic and tonal peak through genuinely funny writing, strong voice performances, and deep customization that reviewers describe with real affection more than a decade on. The specific, well-documented dead-server stuttering bug is concrete and fixable enough to plan around rather than avoid the game over, and the regional censorship and remaster-pricing details are worth checking directly based on your own location and priorities. At its low asking price, this remains an easy, well-earned recommendation for open-world comedy fans, and one of the rare cases in this catalogue where buying the older, cheaper original is the genuinely better-informed choice.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Genuinely funny, absurdist writing and strong voice acting that reviewers consistently rank as the series' comedic peak
- Deep character, vehicle, and weapon customization that reviewers say adds real personal investment beyond the core action gameplay
- Enjoyable, well-supported co-op that multiple reviewers specifically recommend as the best way to experience the game
- Extremely cheap for a substantial, well-regarded open-world campaign, especially relative to the far pricier remaster
- Consistently likable character cast and voice performances, with reviewers naming specific actors and characters they became attached to
Cons
- A specific, well-documented technical problem: the game still attempts to connect to shut-down online services, causing a reproducible stuttering bug affecting even the main menu, requiring a community-made fix guide to resolve
- A regional content issue affecting some countries historically: Australia and Germany received a "low violence" version incompatible with save files from the uncensored release, worth checking directly if you're in an affected region
- One achievement specifically requires uploading a character to now-defunct online servers, requiring a community mod workaround to obtain
- No fast travel system, a specific and frequently repeated complaint from reviewers otherwise positive about the game
- Reports of general stuttering and optimization issues beyond the server-related bug, with some reviewers noting the game runs worse on modern hardware than expected