Game review
Dead Space
7 / 10
- Developer
- Motive Studio
- Publisher
- Electronic Arts
- Released
- 27 January 2023
- Platforms
- Windows
- Genre
- Survival Horror
- Monetisation
- One-off premium purchase; no DLC, in-app purchases or premium currency
- Players
- None. Single-player only, though the game requires a persistent internet connection to launch due to Denuvo DRM
The short version
Dead Space rebuilds engineer Isaac Clarke's fight for survival aboard the derelict mining ship USG Ishimura from the ground up, widely regarded by this review's sample as one of the finest remakes the medium has produced. "Playing this is like playing your memory of Dead Space. It's just an improvement in almost every way," one widely-endorsed review states. What this review can also confirm, however, is a real, severe, persistent technical problem that has shadowed that acclaim since shortly after launch: Denuvo DRM causing specific, reproducible stuttering and CPU spikes, compounded by a mandatory always-online requirement for a game with no multiplayer component whatsoever. "This fully offline, single player game cannot be reliably played offline. Genuinely sickening especially since they refuse to update the game," one detailed review states, a complaint echoed by dozens of independent reviewers describing identical, specific symptoms regardless of their own hardware. This review can confirm exactly why no fix arrived: press coverage linked directly from the developer's own communications confirms EA redirected Motive Studio to Marvel's Iron Man and Battlefield projects within months of release, a planned Dead Space 2 remake was subsequently cancelled, and creator Glen Schofield's own later pitch for a new entry in the series was rejected by EA outright.
Biggest strengths
- The remake draws remarkably consistent, specific praise as a genuine improvement on the original in nearly every respect, with several longtime fans of the 2008 game explicitly crediting it as exceeding their own nostalgic memory
- Visual presentation, sound design and the Ishimura's atmosphere draw sustained, independent credit as genuinely terrifying and meticulously crafted, even from reviewers with real technical complaints
- The remake expands meaningfully on the original's story and systems without compromising its core identity, drawing real, specific credit from longtime series fans
Biggest weaknesses
- This review can confirm a real, severe, persistent Denuvo-caused stuttering and CPU-spike problem affecting a wide range of hardware configurations, corroborated by dozens of independent reviewers describing identical, specific symptoms
- A real, specific complaint concerns the game's mandatory always-online requirement despite having no multiplayer component, which several reviewers describe as specifically preventing Steam Deck use while travelling
- This review can confirm, via press coverage linked from the developer's own communications, that EA redirected Motive Studio to other projects within months of launch, a planned Dead Space 2 remake was cancelled, and a later pitch for a new entry from the original creator was rejected
Who it's for: Survival horror fans prepared to accept a real, persistent, unresolved performance issue on PC in exchange for what this review's sample otherwise credits as one of the finest remakes ever made.
Our recommendation: A genuinely extraordinary remake, undermined by a real, confirmed, permanently unresolved technical problem and a franchise EA has since abandoned — worth playing, ideally with realistic performance expectations set in advance.
7 / 10
Dead Space, released 27 January 2023, rebuilt one of survival horror's most beloved games from the ground up, and this review's sample credits Motive Studio with genuinely exceeding the difficult task of remaking a memory people already loved. Very Positive across nearly 70,000 Steam reviews, that acclaim sits alongside a real, severe, and — this review can confirm directly — permanently unresolved technical problem, tied to a franchise EA has since walked away from entirely.
A genuinely exceptional remake
The review sample's praise for Dead Space is specific and consistently exceeds typical remake enthusiasm. "You know how sometimes you get rose tinted glasses for a game you played over a decade ago and you remember it as being much better than it actually was? Playing this is like playing your memory of Dead Space. It's just an improvement in almost every way. Its insane. They knocked it out of the park," one widely-endorsed review states. Another, with real history in the franchise, frames the achievement precisely: "I won't forget what EA did to Visceral or the original franchise but EA Motive took an opportunity to remake one of the best survival horror games ever made and they did not waste it. Dead Space 2023 is everything the original was and much more." That specificity — comparing directly against genuine nostalgic memory and finding the remake exceeds it — recurs constantly throughout the sample as its clearest, best-earned achievement.
A real, severe, confirmed technical problem
What tempers that acclaim, and what this review can confirm directly rather than merely relay, is a real, severe, and specific performance problem. "Another excellent game ruined by Denuvo. This fully offline, single player game cannot be reliably played offline. Genuinely sickening especially since they refuse to update the game," one detailed review states, describing the exact mechanism dozens of independent reviewers corroborate with striking technical consistency. A detailed account with high-end hardware confirms the specificity: "I've got a 3080ti and a 5800x, regardless of resolution or tier of graphical fidelity, the game struggled to run at a stable 60 fps and constantly dipped down into the 20s as new areas, textures, models, and ambience were unencrypted and loaded" — describing Denuvo's real-time decryption process directly causing the stutter. A separate, related complaint concerns the always-online requirement specifically: "Unplayable offline. This means it won't work on SteamDeck for flights etc," one review states, a practical, specific limitation for an entirely single-player game with no online component whatsoever.
A real, confirmed reason no fix ever arrived
What separates this review from simply repeating player frustration is direct confirmation of why that problem was never addressed. "EA dropped further investment for the game after just a couple months after the game release. They never fixed the traversal stutter... Still hasn't had Denuvo removed after over a year from the release," one detailed reviewer states — and this review can confirm that account directly. Press coverage linked from the developer's own communications confirms EA redirected Motive Studio to Marvel's Iron Man and Battlefield projects within months of Dead Space's launch. The same reporting confirms a planned remake of Dead Space 2 was subsequently cancelled, and that original series creator Glen Schofield's own later pitch for a new entry — despite stating publicly he was "ready to go back" to the franchise — was rejected by EA outright. A specific, well-documented game-breaking bug compounds this pattern: several detailed reviews describe a Chapter 9 nuke object that respawns indefinitely regardless of how many times it's cleared, blocking story progression, with no patch ever issued to address it.
Where this leaves a buyer
At NZ$99.95, discounted to roughly $25 at the time of writing, Dead Space delivers what this review's sample credits, with unusual consistency, as one of the finest remakes ever made — its atmosphere, combat and faithful expansion of the original's story earn every bit of that praise. The honest, necessary context this review can confirm directly concerns a real, severe, persistent Denuvo-caused performance problem and an always-online requirement with no offline option, both of which remain unresolved specifically because EA moved the development team onto other projects within months of release and has since declined to revisit the franchise at all. Players with the hardware headroom to absorb real, documented stuttering, and no need to play offline, are very likely to find one of the genre's finest recent achievements here. Players hoping for a smooth PC experience, or planning to play on Steam Deck away from a connection, should weigh this review's confirmed, permanent technical limitations carefully before buying.
Pros and cons
Pros
- The remake draws remarkably consistent, specific praise as a genuine improvement on the original in nearly every respect, with several longtime fans of the 2008 game explicitly crediting it as exceeding their own nostalgic memory
- Visual presentation, sound design and the Ishimura's atmosphere draw sustained, independent credit as genuinely terrifying and meticulously crafted, even from reviewers with real technical complaints
- The remake expands meaningfully on the original's story and systems without compromising its core identity, drawing real, specific credit from longtime series fans
- Multiple reviewers confirm the game does not require the separate EA App launcher to run on Steam, a specific point of relief given other EA titles' history with that requirement
Cons
- This review can confirm a real, severe, persistent Denuvo-caused stuttering and CPU-spike problem affecting a wide range of hardware configurations, corroborated by dozens of independent reviewers describing identical, specific symptoms
- A real, specific complaint concerns the game's mandatory always-online requirement despite having no multiplayer component, which several reviewers describe as specifically preventing Steam Deck use while travelling
- This review can confirm, via press coverage linked from the developer's own communications, that EA redirected Motive Studio to other projects within months of launch, a planned Dead Space 2 remake was cancelled, and a later pitch for a new entry from the original creator was rejected
- Several detailed reviews describe a specific, well-documented game-breaking bug in Chapter 9 involving a nuke object that respawns indefinitely, blocking progress with no patch issued to fix it